DRAFT 
RESOURCES
Ontology Summit 2008

Information scientists have agreed on a "concept bank" programmers which could use to build an Internet facility called the Open Ontology Repository (OOR). The OOR would comprise diverse collections of concepts (ontologies) such as dictionaries, compendiums of medical terminology, and classifications of products, that could be stored, retrieved, and connected to various bodies of information.
Matthew West (Shell International Petroleum), a member of the advisory committee, is currently developing Shell’s Global Downstream Data Model.
CEE might consider getting involved in this effort while defining the structure of information for their Energy Literacy site.

TheBrain.com

 

Concept Maps

.

NVAC: National Visualization & Analytics Center

NVAC™ provides strategic leadership and coordination for visual analytics technology and tools. It was chartered by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security in 2004. NVAC's R&D agenda for visual analytics to facilitate advanced analytical insight is detailed in a book and video.

Illuminating the Path: The Research and Development Agenda for Visual Analytics


 
NETL: National Energy Technology Laboratory
NETL's Visualization Lab has a dedicated team to assist scientists in their visualization needs. Support can range from writing custom reader modules for visualization applications to helping users operate one of the display systems in the lab.


 
InfoVis Wiki


Courses/Podcasts

Graphic Gems

Commercial Visualization Software

IEA: International Energy Agency

The International Energy Agency (IEA) acts as energy policy advisor to 27 member countries in their effort to ensure reliable, affordable and clean energy for their citizens. Its mandate incorporate the “Three E’s” of balanced energy policy making:

energy security, economic development and environmental protection. Current work focuses on climate change policies, market reform, energy technology collaboration and outreach to the rest of the world.

 
DOE: US Department of Energy

The Energy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy, provides statistics on domestic and international energy

 
NPC: National Petroleum Council

The National Petroleum Council (NPC) was established in 1946 as a federally chartered and privately funded committee. Its purpose is solely to represent the views of the oil and natural gas industries in advising, informing, and making recommendations to the Secretary of Energy with respect to any matter relating to oil and natural gas, or to the oil and gas industries submitted to it or approved by the Secretary.

Hard Truths is NPC's comprehensive view to 2030 of global oil and natural gas, developing a framework in which to consider America’s oil and natural gas position now and for the future. (Slide Presentation)

 
NBER: National Bureau of Economic Research
Founded in 1920, the National Bureau of Economic Research is a private, nonprofit, nonpartisan research organization dedicated to promoting a greater understanding of how the economy works. The NBER is committed to undertaking and disseminating unbiased economic research among public policymakers, business professionals, and the academic community.
NBER Papers in Environmental and Energy Economics

Environmental and Energy Economics

This program studies all aspects of the energy sector and the environment, focusing particularly on their interdependence. Topics include non-energy environmental and natural resource issues, but particular attention is paid to policies that affect all sources of energy, due to that sector's role in national security and as a primary emitter of local, regional, and global pollutants.

 
RMI - Rocky Mountain Institute
Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI) is an independent, entrepreneurial, nonprofit organization dedicated to fostering efficient and restorative use of resources to make the world secure, just, prosperous, and life-sustaining.

RMI's Winning the Oil Endgame offers a strategy for ending US oil dependence led by business for profit.
(Video Podcast)


 
Public Agenda


A nonpartisan opinion research and civic engagement organization helping Americans explore and understand critical issues since 1975.

Putting the Pieces Together: How Do Citizens and Experts See the Energy Issue?
A Report for the Kettering Foundation from Public Agenda
Will Friedman, McKenna Morrigan and Alison Kadlec, February 2008

 

PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES
Energy Positions

 

OTHER ENERGY LITERACY SITES
Energy Literacy Advocates (ELA) is a non-partisan, non-profit, public education and advocacy group. Our mission is to improve the energy literacy of all sectors of our democracy in order to empower and sustain a responsible, comprehensive national energy policy.
BP Statistical Review of World Energy June 2007 - Energy Charting Tool
.Cambridge Energy Research Associates, Inc. (CERA) is a leading advisor to international energy companies, governments, financial institutions, and technology providers. CERA delivers critical knowledge and independent analysis on energy markets, geopolitics, industry trends, and strategy.


IEEE - Power/Energy Website

"The worlds' leading source of technology news and anlysis."

VISUALIZING ENERGY LITERACY

Energy statistics abound. Public understanding does not. Bridging the gap requires taking into account what people want to know about energy and using that as an entry point to insert what they need to know to make informed decisions affecting, not just what it costs to fill up our gas tanks today, but what policies are required for energy security and economic stability tomorrow.

Visualization can play a role in public education. Much work has been done over the last decade to improve technical capabilities in this area. The public is gradually becoming acclimated to sophisticated graphic presentations in the media and on the internet. Business' appetite for graphic presentation of metrics has spawned elaborate, if not always effective, dashboards. What we will try to investigate here are not dashboards, but storyboards to provide information in a manner that is not only accurate and easy to digest, but appealing enough to be selected from the ever growing menu of multimedia choices competing for the public's attention.


CONTEXT

In telling any story, it is important to set the stage. There are many sources of rich of statistics and graphics on energy that can be drawn upon for this purpose. {See examples below.]


SOURCE: NPC, Hard Truths, Slide 27

Visitors to an Energy Literacy website could use such a map as a "drilling platform" from which to access an underlying database of energy information. Depending on the information accessed, visual representations could be overlayed on a physical map, a timeline, a concept map, or presented in a more traditional chart, but one using more effective technology such as Trendalyzer (should it reemerge from Google's skunkworks). Glyphs could be used to encapsulate multiple attributes in a two dimensional space. Below is an example . The first graph is a visual from a DOE report. It provides little information that could be presented more clearly in a standard input output table.

U.S. Primary Energy Consumption by Source and Sector, 2006
(Quadrillion Btu)
 
Transportation
Industrial
Residential &
Commercial
Electric Power
Total
Petroleum
27.5
9.6
2.0
0.8
39.8
Natural Gas
0.7
7.8
7.4
6.5
22.4

Coal

0.0
2.0
0.0
20.6
22.6
Renewable Energy
0.5
1.9
0.6
3.8
6.8
Nuclear Electric Power
0.0
0.0
0.0
8.2
8.2
Total
28.6
21.3
10.0
39.9
99.8

 

The second graph visualizes the same data in a manner that shows the input output relationship of each pairing of an energy source and use. The sources are color coded—blue for Petroleum, red for Nuclear, etc. The box is divided vertically and proportionally according to use by the Transportation, Industrial, Residential & Consumer, and Electric Power sectors. Within each sector's column, the height of a color or type of energy represents its contribution to the sector while the width of the column represents the sector's relative size.

Once a glyph is understood, it's visual signature can be compared over time or over regions. While each glyph or box is divided up proportionately according to sources and uses, the overall size of each glyph can be tied to actual totals. For instance, the box above represents 99.8 quadrillion btu's used in 2006. The boxes below are proportionally smaller, representing roughly half and two-thirds the overall use displayed in the first glyph. The color "signatures" also indicate different relative sources and sector sizes.

Country or regional glyphs can be arrayed on a map, providing comparable energy information within a geographic context.


The map and glyphs could also serve as a portal to county or region specific information sources.


TRANSMISSION

All the oil in Saudi Arabia would be of little value if there were no means of delivering it to heat homes, fuel cars, or power factories. Similarly, a presentation is not effective unless its message can be transmitted and received. Any broadbased literacy program will need to take into account where people go for their information and how they retrieve it. This could include, among other targeted efforts:

  • a Press Release program for traditional print media such as community newspapers and
  • either direct management of a proprietary, controlled contribution Energy Wiki
  • or proactive placement of links in, contributions to, and correction of material in Wikipedia itself.


Access to the K-12 arena is more problematic given the crush of requirements with which teachers are faced. However, it may be possible to insert high quality materials that help educators satisfy these requirements through the burgeoning homeschool market and through programs such as the Verizon Foundation's Thinkfinity, an online lesson plan resource. Energy content to this site was supplied by the National Geographic Education Foundation, the American Association for the Advancement of Science / Science Net Links, and the National Council on Economic Education's EconEdLink. Note that content providers must meet rigorous requirements.

Another model for this type of effort is the collaboration between the Stanford Solar Insitute and Local Schools. (See, A Unique Collaboration Between Scientists and Educators)

Another potential course of action would be preparation and free distribution over the internet of all materials necessary for a course in Energy Literacy to be used, for instance, in

  • Service-Learning
  • Continuing Education
  • Community Colleges
  • In-Service Programs for K-12 Teachers and
  • School of Education Methods Courses for pre-service teachers

All materials would start from the perspective of consumers' immediate, personal concerns, and evolve organically like Mind Maps generating a better understanding of the long term implications of global supply and demand relationships and the role individuals play in them. Preparation of the materials might be done with a partner such as the Center for Science and Mathematics Education at The University of Texas at Austin, a research, teaching, and service unit located in the College of Education or with a similar group devoted to Social Studies Education. This effort should be accompanied by a training program for course providers. Developing it within a College of Education and for a Methods Course would serve multipe goals of development, educatior preparation, and school insertion.

It also would be helpful to identify associations and organizations which would

  • encourage members to provide the Energy Literacy course as a community service as well as
  • offer course instructor preparation during the course of their normal meetings or conferences.

It would wise to structure this effort to reflect the service or continued learning requirements of partner associations which might include the following:

  • International Association for Energy Economics (IAEE)
  • National Youth Leadership Council (NYLC),
  • Federal Reserve Bank Branche education offices (FRED)
  • National Association for Business Economics (NABE)
  • Society of Financial Analysts(SFA)
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR ENERGY ECONOMICS
NATIONAL YOUTH LEADERSHIP COUNCIL

FEDERAL
RESERVE EDUCATION

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR BUSINESS ECONOMICS
SOCIETY OF FINANCIAL ANALYSTS

Other potential partners would include high tech companies with strong track records in democratizing visualization such as Google (Earth) and IBM (Many Eyes).

GOOGLE EARTH
 
MANY EYES

The National Laboratories may also provide partnering opportunites for education initiatives involving energy and visualization, particularly

  • PNNL, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, home to NVAC, the National Visualization and Analytics Center
  • NETL, the National Energy Technology Laborator, which also houses a Visualization Lab and
  • NREL, the National Renewable Energy Laboratory

NREL promotes excellence in teaching and learning and contributes to improving critical elements of the science, mathematics, and technology education system. Teachers are offered research and development opportunities to enhance their content knowledge, instructional strategies, and leadership abilities.

MODE

Visualizations run the gamut from simple bar charts to fully interactive 3-D applications. It may appear that younger audiences require "glitzier" presentations, however, content is still key for .holding their attention. Depth and drilldown capability, complexity with clarity, and a good storyline are necessary elements for students with plenty of other attention grabbing options. On the high end of content and complexity, see for instance the online version of the New York Metropolitan Museum of Art exhibit Design and the Elastic Mind. The computer interface will likely delight the MP3 generation and quickly confound or frustrate their parental units. Try typing in "ENERGY" in the Search Box - finding which may require patience, bifocals, or both. You are on your own in learning to navigate the links, a task with which a pre-would have no difficulty.
 

Emergent Surface, a dynamic architectural facade which responds to people's movements and exterior weather changes - From MOMA's exhibit, Design and the Elastic Mind.
 
On the other end of the technical spectrum of visualization tools for energy literacy are "Concept Maps" which require only paper, pencil, and a vivid imagination to help a child to develop their own storyline. A wonderful collection of Energy concept maps was produced by science/medical writing students at the University of Kansa one of which is shown below.

SOURCE: travisenergymap.jpg in http://science.journalism.ku.edu/upload/2006/02/energymaps/ Produced by science/medical writing students in the William Allen White School of Journalism & Mass Communications at the University of Kansas.


OTHER ENERGY VISUALIZATION EXAMPLES

ENERGY BAR CHARTS
FINAL CONSUMPTION BY REGION
 
PRIMARY ENERGY BY SOURCE
 



   
U.S. ENERGY FLOW - STATIC
 
U.S. ENERGY FLOW - COMPARATIVE STATICS
 
SOURCE: DOE, Annual Energy Review, 2006  


   
DYNAMIC ILLUSTRATION OF FRACTIONAL DISTILLATION -- click on image to demonstrate  
TIMELINES & SCENARIOS
 
SOURCE: How Stuff Works   SOURCE: Shell Energy Scenarios to 2050
     
ENERGY FOOTPRINTS: WALKING THROUGH THE ENERGY SECTOR
OF AN INPUT OUPUT MODEL

This simple interview shows the power of storytelling in explaining the pervasiveness of carbon footprints in our daily lives. It is also an interesting way of introducing the concept of the energy sector in an economic input-output model without ever mentioning any of those user-unfriendly words. This sort of video could be used to prime participants to create a map of energy use in their own lives, to think beyond the gas pump and heating oil tank to the energy components of their food and clothing and their entertainment, and work habits. An activity might include one like listing all the points at which energy enters a glass of wine (of milk) that we drink, starting with the sun that makes the grapes or grass grow, the electricity that runs the processing equipment, including production of the containers to hold the liquids, and the fuel to deliver it to the store, to drive to pick it up, and to bring that fuel from its source through refining and to the pump. It could be a very large energy map indeed..

     
     
     

 

Contact Information:
Email: info@inkweb.org



RETURN TO TOP